Best Motorcycle Top Box


Author:
Last Updated: 21st August 2020

Still using a heavy rucksack while riding?

If so, it is time to upgrade your motorcycle luggage.

A motorcycle top box (also called hard tail bag or top case) is a good way to add lots of extra storage to your bike and keep items secure.

The best motorcycle top boxes can be pricey investments though.

Here’s what you need to know to get the best quality top box for your money.

Our Top Pick

Givi V47N

Roomy, Sturdy, Lightweight

Oozing with quality throughout, this 47l box is perfect for commuters and day trippers. Check SportsBikeShop

Budget Pick

Ryde 32l

Cheap and Capable

If you only need a small top box for inexpensive items go for the Ryde 32 litre.

For such a cheap top box, its construction and design are fantastic. Check Amazon

5 Best Motorcycle Top Boxes Reviewed

Read on to get the lowdown on our favourite products.


Givi V47N Monokey Top Case

Top All Rounder

This 47 litre box from Givi seems to be the sweet spot in capacity for many riders. Will fit a lid easily with plenty of space left over for boots, clothes etc.

Fantastic build quality is a given with Givi and this box is no exception. From the smooth opening action to the foolproof locking mechanism everything just works.

Uses the excellent Givi mounting plate (you’ll have to by this separately) which allows for quick release and is extremely stable when the bike is moving.

Check Prices on SportsBikeShop

Pros

plus iconLightweight yet sturdy

plus icon Fully waterproof

plus iconQuick release fixing system

plus iconMax load 10kg

Cons

minus iconNeed to buy separate mounting plate

minus iconGivi quality comes at a price

Check SportsBikeShop


Ryde 32l Motorcycle Top Box

Budget Pick

Considering how cheap the Ryde top box is, it has a lot of impressive features. I guess it’s not too surprising since they seemed to copy the design from a certain other well known brand-name!

At 32 litres, the Ryde can still surprisingly hold a decent amount of gear including a full-face helmet and some extras. Compared to other cheap top boxes, the fitting system is very secure. It uses 4 hooks instead of the 2 that most cheap top boxes use.

You have to keep the key in the cylinder to lock this top box, so there’s no risk of your keys getting accidentally locked inside. Note though that you have to push on the latch to lock the thing. It took me 10 minutes to figure that out!

Check Prices on Amazon

Pros

plus iconCheap

plus icon Fits more than you’d think

plus iconSecure fitting system

plus iconCan’t lock keys inside accidentally

Cons

minus iconNo fitting instructions

minus iconWouldn’t trust this lock against thieves

Check On Amazon


Givi E300N Monolock Top Box

Cheaper Givi

If you aren’t ready to shell out a lot of money for a Monokey Givi top box, the Givi E300N is an affordable Monolock alternative. It is very cheap but still offers the reliability you’d expect with Givi products.

At 30 liters, the top box will only hold 1 helmet and some small items. There aren’t any straps or pockets inside, so you’ll have to be careful when opening the case to make sure everything doesn’t fall out.

Some people did report problems when trying to fit it to their bikes. However, Givi is a popular brand so you should be able to find bike-specific mounting advice online.

Check Prices on SportsBikeShop

Pros

plus iconAffordable

plus icon Sturdy construction

plus iconGood waterproofness

Cons

minus iconMight have trouble fitting it to some bikes

minus iconNo internal straps or pockets

Check SportsBikeShop Check On Amazon


Givi Trekker Monokey TRK46N 46 Liter Top Box

Quality Pick

This is one of the most popular motorcycle top boxes by Givi. People mostly love it because of its cool opening and partitioning method. You can either fully open it on the hinge, or you can open just part of the lid – which is useful if you are trying to get small items out of the top box without spilling everything all over the road.

I also appreciate that the key has to be in the cylinder to lock the top box. This way, you can’t lock your keys inside.

Some people love the aluminium style of the Trekker case. I personally find it too boxy looking and don’t like how rain falls on it. It seems you’ll either love it or hate it though.

Check Prices on SportsBikeShop

Pros

plus iconFits two helmets plus other gear easily

plus icon Sturdy mount

plus iconSecure locking mechanism and construction

plus iconStraps for securing items in place

plus iconCan’t lock keys inside

plus iconCompletely waterproof

Cons

minus iconPricy investment

minus iconIsn’t the most attractive top box

Check SportsBikeShop Check On Amazon


Givi V56N Maxia 4 Monokey Top Case

Best For Size

Givi 56N Top Box

The Givi Maxia has a 56 litre capacity, making it one of the biggest top boxes that you’ll find. You’ll easily fit two helmets plus some clothing and spare bits. It doesn’t cost much more than the smaller Givi top boxes, so it is worth it to buy this case if you need lots of storage.

As you’d expect from Givi, the design of the top box is very nice. It has a document pocket and elastic belts for securing items. The handle folds right into the case.

There is a hinge mechanism inside the top which allows the lid to stay open while you load it. The top box is easily removed so you can use the case like large luggage.

My only issue with the Givi Maxia is that it can be locked without the key in the cylinder, meaning you could lock your keys inside. As a forgetful person, I’d rather not have this risk.

Check Prices on SportsBikeShop

Pros

plus iconHolds tons of gear

plus icon Affordable compared to similar products

plus iconOne-handed opening

plus iconShape directs rain away from pillion

plus iconDocument pocket and straps

Cons

minus iconCould accidentally lock keys in box

minus iconSize definitely affects handling at high speeds

Check SportsBikeShop


HOMCOM 24L Motorcycle Top Box

Bargain Basement

The HOMCOM top box stands out for being incredibly cheap. Despite its low price, the top box is still built well. I haven’t heard of any incidences of it cracking or the lock breaking.

As expected with a cheap motorcycle top box, you won’t get extra features or a thief-proof lock. The real issue is the size of the top box. If you have a larger full-face helmet (such as one with vents), it might not fit into the HOMCOM.

Dimensions of the HOMCOM top box are 40(l)x38(w)x28(h). Measure your helmet carefully before buying this top box.

Check Prices on Amazon

Pros

plus iconVery cheap

plus icon Decent locking mechanism

plus iconSturdy construction

Cons

minus iconSmall size

minus iconMight not fit your full-face helmet

minus iconNo guidance for fitting

Check On Amazon


Why Would You Want a Motorcycle Top Box?


A lot of people hate motorcycle top boxes because they “ruin” the aesthetics of the bike. I’m a very rational person though and the practical benefits of top boxes outweigh the aesthetic argument.

Pros 

  • Less wind drag than tank bags or panniers
  • Doesn’t add to width of bike (better for squeezing through rush hour traffic)
  • Are often waterproof
  • Provide good protection for items like laptops and paperwork
  • Easy to put on/take off
  • Lockable
  • Pillion can use as a backrest. Recommended reading – Ultimate guide to  riding pillion
  • You can strap other items onto the top box
  • Doubles as a travel sink

Cons 

  • Higher load affects balance
  • Can affect motorcycle handling
  • Tend to be overloaded

Warning about Overloading

Motorbike overloaded with luggage
I think we may be overloaded!

Many people in biker forums recommend going with larger top boxes because “you can always use more storage.”

Yes – having storage is great, but it can cause some problems if you go too large.

  • Overloading: People have a tendency to overload top boxes. Even the best top boxes have a max capacity of around 10kg. Too much weight can make your bike wobble and throws the centre of gravity off. Be careful!
  • Difficulty Handling: Even empty top boxes will still add a lot of weight to your bike. If you have a small bike, are going off road, or go at high speeds, this can really affect handling.
  • Damage to the Bike: If you really overload your top box, you could crack your rear frame. During off-roading, the stress from the top box can also break the sub-frame.

In short, don’t buy a huge top box for a tiny bike. And (regardless of bike size) never overload your top box. 

How to Choose 


Motorcycle top boxes range from the ultra-cheap to expensive products by top brand names. Bear in mind that there is no one best motorcycle top box for all bikes. It depends on how you want to use it.

Top Box Size and Shape

As a general rule, you need to get a motorcycle top box which is big enough to fit the following items:

For solo riders, this means getting at least 37 litres. If you have a pillion or armour on your jacket, you’ll probably need at least 46 litres.

Be aware that the shape of the top box can affect how much it will hold. An awkward shape makes it harder to get items inside.

It’s easy to test how big of a top box you need. Just grab your gear and try to pack it up. Measure how much space it takes up in litres (I shoved my gear into a 50 litre cool box to gauge the size).

Top tip: To get everything to fit in your top box, try this method. First lay your jacket into the top box with the zipper-side up. Make a “nest” for your helmet to sit in. Then fold the jacket sleeves up around the helmet.

Fitting Method

To fit a top box to your motorcycle, you will need to have some hardware. First you’ll need the mounting plate for the top box. This almost always comes with the top box – but check to make sure you don’t need to buy it separately!

Then you will need a bike-specific mounting kit for attaching the plate to the bike rack (if you still don’t have a bike rack, now is the time to get one).

I’ve heard of people using generic-brand mounting kits because they are cheaper than the bike-specific brand name ones. However, you’ve got to be careful about doing this. The generic kits don’t always attach well. You might end up with a wobbly mount.

Top tip: Look for a top box mount which has a lockable quick-release feature. This makes it easy to remove your top box and carry it as luggage.

Locking Mechanism

One of the main benefits of top boxes is that they can be locked, allowing you to leave your items behind with the bike. It beats carrying a motorcycle helmet with you around town.

Be warned that even the best boxes are still susceptible to theft. It only takes a teen with a screwdriver and some patience to separate you from your top box.

That said, the best top boxes will provide some degree of theft protection. In the video below, you can see how a thief unsuccessfully tried to break into a Givi top box.

The thief destroyed the lock in the process but luckily Givi makes replacement locks.

Monokey vs. Monolock

Givi’s boxes feature their patented “Monokey” or “Monolock” system.

The Monokey system means you can use the same key for the lid and base plate. You can even match the lock to all of your other Givi Monokey luggage. This saves you the hassle of carrying an extra key. The Monokey lock is also much sturdier than universal mounts.

By contrast, Monolock top boxes use a universal mount which can’t be used with Monokey luggage. You can’t reduce the number of keys required, and the locking mechanism tends not to be as sturdy.

The difference is well explained in the video below.

Buying tip: Consider whether you might accidentally lock the keys inside the box. Many top boxes can only be locked while the key is inside the lock, preventing you from doing this.

Brand Name vs. Generic Motorcycle Top Cases

I love brands like Givi for motorcycle gear. But, I also know that you can find seemingly identical gear by generic brands for a fraction of the cost.

Choose a Brand Name Top Box If:

  • You store valuable items in your top box and don’t want to trust them to a cheap top box
  • You park your bike in areas where it is vulnerable to theft
  • You want access to spare parts
  • You need good instructions on how to fit the top box

Choose a Cheap Generic Top Box If:

  • Your budget can’t afford brand-name gear
  • You only use your top box for storing your lunch on the way to work
  • The product got lots of good reviews

Image Credits

Bike of Burden in Vietnam flickr photo by graeme_newcomb shared under a Creative Commons (BY) license